Why the First Medication Isn't Always the One That Sticks
For some people, the first medication they try works really well. For others, it doesn't, and that can be discouraging.
I'm Christopher Schuman, a board-certified psychiatric nurse practitioner serving patients in Texas, Washington, and New Mexico. Here's why that happens, and what a fair trial looks like.
Start With the Strategy
When a first medication doesn't work, I like to back up and look at the original plan.
- Was medication the right first step? Or was it started because something else didn't work, or because there was some urgency?
- Was there a good trial of therapy, and did it feel helpful?
- What was the medication started for?
That last question matters. Anxiety, for example, can be treated with medication in two different ways. Some medications act quickly and are meant for situational anxiety. Antidepressants are a longer-term strategy, mainly for people dealing with chronic worry. If someone takes an antidepressant because they hate flying, it's not going to fix that.
Everyone's Body Is Different
If you've never taken a medication like this before, we don't know yet how your body breaks it down. Some people process a medication very efficiently and need a higher dose than expected. Others are very sensitive to it.
Start Low
That's why I usually start with the lowest dose. Some people on SSRIs feel flat or apathetic. Patients sometimes say it made them feel like a zombie. That's generally a sign the medication is too potent for that person, and they need less of it, not more.
Feeling that way can turn people off medication altogether, so the goal is to avoid it. We start low and wait four to six weeks. If you don't notice a difference, we increase it a little. Undershooting is easy to fix. Overshooting is what we're trying to avoid.
What a Fair Trial Looks Like
In general, a fair trial is at least four to six weeks at two different doses. I don't usually recommend pushing all the way to the maximum dose. If someone hasn't felt any better well into the higher range, going to the very top is unlikely to change that.
If a couple of dose changes haven't made a difference, we may try a different medication. Some people have genetic differences that make certain medications less effective for them, or that affect how quickly their body clears a medication. When someone has tried several medications without results, or has had a lot of side effects, genetic testing can sometimes point toward options that may fit better. I don't use it routinely, and not every insurance plan covers it, but it can help in the right situation.
Sometimes the Answer Isn't a New Medication
When someone tells me a medication isn't working, it doesn't always mean we switch. Sometimes it means going back to the drawing board and asking what we're really treating.
Depression and anxiety involve a lot of different symptoms, and a lot of different circumstances in someone's life can feed into them. Expecting one capsule to fix all of it is a lot to ask.
If the main problem is fatigue, I want to know about sleep. Are you waking up at four in the morning worrying about things? We can work on that. One tool I use is the 10-3-2-1 rule:
- 10 hours before bed: no more caffeine
- 3 hours before bed: no vigorous exercise
- 2 hours before bed: finish your last meal
- 1 hour before bed: no screens
If brain fog is the issue, a walk in the morning can help. Creatine is another option some patients add alongside treatment. The brain has its own creatine system that helps it use energy, and there's evidence supporting creatine as an add-on. Check with your provider before starting any supplement.
There are a lot of reasons a first medication might not work. Figuring out which one applies to you is part of the process.
← Back to all posts